Success Stories: R&D Investment at Work

Teachers Helping Teachers Improve Math Instruction in West Virginia

See how strategic federal investments turn research into results. Through stories like Mountaineer Mathematics Master Teachers (M3T)—where federal funding helped scale a teacher-led network that improves student achievement—we show how education R&D strengthens learning outcomes and better prepares America’s students for future success.

Mountaineer Mathematics Master Teachers (M3T) is a statewide, teacher-led network working to strengthen middle and high school mathematics teaching and learning across West Virginia. Through teacher collaboration, research-informed practices, and classroom data, M3T helps educators identify challenges, test instructional strategies, and use student feedback to refine their practice.

Turning Education R&D Investments into Impact

Mountaineer Mathematics Master Teachers (M3T) is helping West Virginia educators strengthen mathematics instruction through teacher-led improvement efforts supported by federal and state investments in education R&D.

$ 2.9 million

from an NSF Noyce Teacher Scholarship grant

$ 75000

from a National Science Foundation Noyce Capacity Building grant

$ 900000

in support from the West Virginia Department of Education

$ 400000

from participating districts to support improvement team participant stipends

West Virginia HB 5405 established a state grant program offering up to $1 million annually in competitive grants, with a minimum 25% district match

The impact of these investments is clear:

  • More than 400 math teachers across 48 West Virginia districts have participated in the network, reaching more than 37,000 students in grades 6-12.
  • 92.5% of M3T Local Improvement Team participants surveyed reported that their teaching had improved as a result of the program.
  • 65% of M3T Local Improvement Team participants surveyed said they planned to remain in teaching “as long as I am able,” compared with 22% of other West Virginia teachers.
  • Between 2021 and 2025, participating districts’ pass rates on 8th-grade end-of-year high-stakes assessments saw double the growth of non-participating districts.
  • Controlling for prior math achievement and demographics, eighth graders who had M3T teachers for two years scored significantly higher on the state math assessment than their peers.

Teachers Helping Teachers Improve Math Instruction in West Virginia

West Virginia’s Mountaineer Mathematics Master Teachers (M3T) network started out as a teacher-led effort to improve mathematics instruction in Pocahontas County. The effort gained traction through its unique approach, which put teachers at the center of instructional improvement. Teachers worked together to identify challenges, develop solutions, and strengthen their instructional practices, ultimately contributing to gains in mathematics achievement. The work caught the attention of researchers at West Virginia University, and with support from the U.S. National Science Foundation (NSF), the local effort grew into a statewide network. Today, M3T connects educators across the state to identify instructional challenges, test changes in their classrooms, and use student feedback and classroom data to refine their practice.

Early federal investments helped M3T develop its approach and expand beyond Pocahontas County. In 2018, the network partnered with West Virginia University and received a $75,000 NSF Noyce Capacity Building grant to refine its model and engage district leaders across the state. From 2020 to 2026, nearly $3 million in additional NSF funding supported further development and expansion. The West Virginia Department of Education contributes $900,000 toward this work, and participating districts provide $400,000 to support the network and teacher participation.

“As legislative leaders in West Virginia, we are committed to advancing legislation and using taxpayer dollars to implement innovative solutions that show real results and return on investment. M3T does just that, while affirming our commitment to teacher leadership. I cannot think of a better way to invest in education than investing in our own teachers. I look forward to seeing more positive results from M3T in the future.”
– Senator Amy Grady West Virginia Legislature

Evidence-Based Practices

M3T has developed a unique application of improvement science to help math teachers in grades 6-12 address instructional challenges in their own classrooms. Rather than asking every educator to adopt the same intervention, the network gives teachers a structured process for identifying problems, exploring potential solutions, and testing changes on a small scale. Teachers draw on research and colleagues’ experiences, then use student feedback and classroom data to determine which approaches to adopt, adapt, or abandon.

The network is organized into teacher-led Local Improvement Teams and Grade-level Improvement Teams. Experienced middle and secondary mathematics teachers serve as Math Teacher Leaders and receive annual $10,000 stipends and ongoing coaching from the project lead to facilitate professional development and collaboration outside school hours.

Local Improvement Teams use student surveys to understand students’ experiences in math class, while Grade-level Improvement Teams analyze high-stakes assessment data to identify opportunities to strengthen student learning. Teachers test changes in two- to four-week cycles using common measures and share their findings at statewide network meetings. These exchanges allow educators to learn from one another, compare results, and adapt promising approaches across district lines.

The network’s structure gives teachers a way to test new approaches and learn from the results without having to navigate challenges alone. Elaine Cook, a teacher and MTL, described her experience: “We’re collecting data, we’re doing it thoughtfully, we’re planning, we’re researching, but it’s that idea of trying something in a short amount of time and being willing to take the risk. And also, you’re not going to be on your own when you take that risk. You’re going to have other people that give you input when you look at your data, and if you feel like it’s not working well, you have people to ask ‘What can I do to make it better, or should I just abandon it?’”

A Lincoln County LIT illustrates how this process works. Teachers in grades 6-12 found that many students reported rarely defending their approaches to solving math problems, a practice that supports mathematical reasoning. The team explored research for potential solutions but did not find an approach that met its needs. At an M3T network meeting, members learned that another LIT had found success with Gallery Walks, which invite students to share their solutions and explain their reasoning to classmates.

The Lincoln County teachers tested Gallery Walks in their classrooms, surveying students before introducing the activity to establish a baseline. Follow-up surveys suggested that more students were explaining their mathematical thinking. Survey feedback also helped the team identify opportunities to refine the activity.

The Impact

M3T has reached more than 400 teachers across 48 districts in West Virginia, supporting mathematics instruction for more than 37,000 students in grades 6-12. Fifty-three Math Teacher Leaders have helped educators collaborate across district lines and share promising practices.

An independent evaluation by WestEd examined West Virginia Department of Education data to assess the relationship between M3T participation and student mathematics achievement. Researchers analyzed assessment results for students in grades 6-8, comparing students taught by M3T-participating teachers with matched comparison students while controlling for prior achievement and demographic factors.

The evaluation found that students taught by M3T-participating teachers for two years scored significantly higher in mathematics than matched comparison students. These students gained the equivalent of roughly one full additional academic year of learning compared to their matched peers. An even stronger effect was found among students taught directly by Math Teacher Leaders for two years, and these effects are considered large for educational interventions. Overall, the findings provide promising evidence that sustained, teacher-led professional learning is associated with improvements in student achievement.

As the NSF funding period comes to a close, state leaders are working to sustain the network through continued state and district investment. In 2025, Senator Amy Grady and Delegate Joe Statler championed legislation establishing a state grant program, administered by the West Virginia Department of Education, to help districts partner with M3T. Eight districts received funding for 2025-2026, and 18 are receiving funding for 2026-2027. This grant program offers a path for M3T to continue its work beyond the federal funding period, with state and district investment helping sustain the network for years to come.

Education R&D Playbook in Practice

West Virginia’s M3T network exemplifies two key recommendations from ALI’s State Education R&D Playbook: 1) Establish networks and 2) Change mindsets and behaviors.

What began as a local, teacher-led effort grew into a statewide network through university partnerships and federal investment. Now, West Virginia is investing in the network’s continued operation through a state grant program to help districts partner with M3T. By sustaining M3T, the state is helping educators continue to test new approaches, learn from results, and refine their practice, making continuous improvement part of how teachers work. The effort demonstrates how states can build on local innovation, connect educators across districts, and invest in sustaining networks that support continuous improvement.